A section of sidewalk lifted by a tree root can look harmless until your shoe catches the edge and a routine walk ends in injury. When tree root sidewalk damage causes a trip-and-fall accident, figuring out who is responsible is rarely simple. Finding the answer requires determining who owns the property, who owns the tree, and whether anyone knew about the problem beforehand.
An NYC sidewalk accident lawyer can review those details and explain how the rules apply to your fall. Whether responsibility falls on the building owner, the City, or someone else, an attorney can help you determine your next steps.
How Tree Roots Damage NYC Sidewalks
New York City has more than 12,000 miles of sidewalks, and more than 650,000 street trees throughout the five boroughs. While trees are a vital part of the city’s character, they can also cause damage as their roots grow and expand under sidewalks, lifting and cracking sections.
Even a small lip or bump in the sidewalk can be enough to cause someone to trip and fall, resulting in injuries that range from minor scrapes and bruises to more severe sprains, broken bones, and head trauma.
According to the NYC Comptroller, 2,350 sidewalk personal injury claims were filed against the City in fiscal year 2023. The figure covers sidewalk claims generally, not just falls involving tree roots, and doesn’t include claims made solely against private parties.
Sorting Out NYC Sidewalk Liability
When someone falls and tries to figure out who’s liable, responsibility often rests with the adjoining property owner or the City, though other parties may also share fault. Different rules and deadlines apply to injury claims against each. A sidewalk accident attorney in New York can help you explore liability and your legal path forward.
The Property Owner’s Side
Under NYC Administrative Code 7-210, property owners generally must keep adjoining sidewalks reasonably safe and may be liable for injuries caused by negligent maintenance. For properties covered by that liability rule, damage caused by a City-owned tree does not automatically excuse the owner. Property owners can be liable for injury claims when they fail to repair a known defect.
There is a notable exception. Section 7-210’s injury-liability rule doesn’t apply to one-, two-, or three-family properties that are at least partly owner-occupied and used exclusively as residences.
An owner may still be liable for creating the dangerous condition, if applicable. Still, an injury alone does not establish negligence. An NYC sidewalk accident lawyer can examine whether the owner created the defect, knew about it, or should have discovered it through reasonable inspection. The condition must also have caused the fall and injuries.
The City’s Side
The City may be responsible for sidewalk injuries beside qualifying owner-occupied homes or City-owned property. However, City ownership of a street tree does not, by itself, establish responsibility for damage to the surrounding sidewalk.
NYC Parks’ Trees & Sidewalks Program offers free repairs for qualifying sidewalks severely damaged by street-tree roots beside one-, two-, and three-family residential properties. The City inspects requested sites and ranks them for repair. According to NYC DOT, the City replaces more than two million square feet of sidewalk annually.
However, that work doesn’t make the City liable for every unrepaired slab. Under NYC Administrative Code 7-201, the City is generally not liable for a sidewalk defect unless it received prior written notice of the condition, with limited exceptions.
Earlier complaints about municipal sidewalk maintenance and Parks inspection records can help document the condition. However, a 311 complaint alone does not necessarily meet the City’s prior-written-notice requirement.
How Tree Wells Affect Liability
Tree wells, the soil areas surrounding street trees, further complicate liability questions for tree-root-related trip-and-fall accidents. Whether your foot caught raised concrete or you stepped into the dirt opening around the tree can point to different responsible parties.
The New York Court of Appeals has held that tree wells are outside the sidewalk liability transfer under Section 7-210. A nearby owner is therefore not automatically responsible under that law for a defect inside a City-owned tree well. An owner or contractor could still face responsibility for creating a hazard, such as unsafe edging.
An NYC sidewalk accident lawyer can investigate whether exposed roots inside the well or roots lifting the surrounding pavement caused the accident.
How Premises Liability Claims Weigh Fault
Liability for sidewalk trip-and-fall injury claims generally turns on a few questions.
- Who was responsible for keeping the area reasonably safe?
- Was the condition dangerous?
- Did that party create the hazard, know about it, or have a reasonable opportunity to discover and address it?
- Did the condition cause the fall and injuries?
More than one party can share fault in a trip-and-fall accident. For example, perhaps residents of an apartment building reported a damaged sidewalk slab outside the building, and the owner hired a contractor to perform repairs. The contractor failed to adequately fix the problem, and the damage sat unaddressed for an extended period. The contractor may be liable for negligent maintenance, while the building owner may be responsible for failing to adequately address a known hazard.
New York also applies comparative negligence under CPLR 1411, which means a recovery can be reduced by the percentage of fault assigned to the injured person.
What Evidence Makes a Sidewalk Case Clearer?
Your case needs evidence tied to your fall. After seeking appropriate medical care for your trip-and-fall injuries, take these steps to preserve evidence for your sidewalk accident lawyer in NYC:
- Photograph the raised edge, nearby tree, and surrounding walkway.
- Include wider views showing the building address.
- Record witness names and contact details.
- Save footwear, medical records, receipts, and missed-work information.
- Write down what caught your foot while the details are fresh.
An NYC sidewalk accident lawyer may review ownership records, earlier photographs, repair permits, and complaints to clarify how long the defect existed and who was responsible.
Discuss Your Sidewalk Injury With a Sidewalk Accident Lawyer in NYC
Tree roots, shared duties, and city notice rules make these situations harder to sort out than they first appear. An NYC sidewalk accident lawyer at Ross & Hill can help you understand how to file a sidewalk trip-and-fall claim after a tree-related fall. Call (646) 351-6222 to request a free consultation to discuss your legal options.
Frequently Asked Questions
These common questions cover property owner responsibility, sidewalk repairs, and what to expect when making a claim after a tree-root trip-and-fall accident.
Who Is Responsible When Tree Roots Lift an NYC Sidewalk?
The adjoining property owner generally must keep the sidewalk reasonably safe, even when the tree belongs to the City. Different injury-liability rules apply to one-, two-, and three-family properties that are at least partly owner-occupied and used exclusively as residences.
Is a Homeowner Responsible for Repairing Sidewalk Damage From a City Tree?
Tree-root damage beside one-, two-, and three-family residential properties may qualify for free repairs through NYC Parks’ Trees & Sidewalks Program. NYC Parks inspects sites and ranks them for repair. Owners who arrange repairs independently must obtain the required permits.
How Long Do You Have to Take Action After a Sidewalk Trip-and-Fall?
For a typical sidewalk injury claim against the City, you or your NYC sidewalk accident lawyer generally must serve a notice of claim within 90 days of the accident and file a lawsuit within one year and 90 days. You must file a personal injury lawsuit against a private property owner within three years of the accident. Exceptions can affect these deadlines.